At long
last, some decent YA paranormal romance comes my way. This week’s book was The First Book of Demons, by Raquel
Dove. As you might have guessed, it’s the first book in a series about demons.
Full of demons, magic, and awkward teenage sex, this story builds an engaging
world and a romance worth cheering for. While the plot could have used a little
more foreshadowing and emphasis on the most important moment, The First Book of Demons—while no great
work of literature—is engaging enough to keep the reader reading, even when it
means not reading the two papers I was assigned for my laboratory course today.
Oh, well, it was worth it.
Digging the fonts. And the fangs. |
Balthazar
has some big problems. His father’s just been assassinated and he’s got to
ascend to the throne of the Devas. To do this, he’ll have to uncover the
traitors in his court, marry a princess . . . and an ancient demon sage tells
him he’ll also need a human. Happily, Alex turns up a few short chapters later.
The two can’t stand each other at first, but, c’mon, we can all tell the
attraction is there. Sure, Balthazar’s a bit of an asshole—hey, a demonic
sultan has to have a harem full of concubines, right—but I found this romance to
be one worth rooting for. Can Balthazar secure his father’s throne? Will Alex
ever loose her virginity? It’s a fun ride, as long as you don’t take it too
seriously. Sit back, relax, and enjoy the dialogue.
And now I’m
going to rip a little. The amount of ripping is not proportional to my enjoyment of the book.
My big
problem was with the flow of the plot. Storylines appear and disappear. We see
Alex’s aunt die, but she’s sad for a while and then the sadness goes away, even
though it’s just been a few weeks. Her missing parents are mentioned in the
beginning and at the end, but we don’t see Alex really think about them too
much. Alex and Balthazar go on a quest to find magical objects . . . and yet
the object attained as a result of said adventure has no effect on the climax. There’s
a demon king threatening to invade Balthazar’s land, but we don’t see him, any
of his people, and the threat doesn’t feel real and immediate.
The story
switches between antagonists—usurpers in the palace trying to claim Balthazar’s
throne, enemy kingdoms who’ll declare war if Balthazar doesn’t mate with the king’s
daughter, a mysterious cult of mysterious mages. Personally, I think it would
have been better if it had focused on only one antagonist, with another threat
maybe lurking in the background. I get that it’s a series, but every
installment in a series—especially the first book—should have a self-contained
arc. As it was, I wasn’t sure who the final villain would be.
When the
evil plan was revealed, I didn’t have an ‘aha’ moment—a moment where all the
clues came together and I realized that this evil conspiracy had been hidden in
plain sight all along. Don’t get me wrong, I’m not saying the bad guys weren’t
foreshadowed, but Alex doesn’t really have an emotional connection with them. If
Alex had known about them and seen their actions throughout the story, they
would be much stronger villains. Instead, they only come into direct conflict
with the main characters at the end.
High:
Originality. I liked the idea of a world where humans were considered magical
creatures. Readability. The tone is very good. It feels professional and
well-edited. Dialogue. It’s very snappy and witty. Character creation.
Balthazar’s a great character, as far as morally ambiguous characters go. Tone.
This story feels professionally edited.
Low: Lack
of scenery description. Mountains and forests are mentioned in certain places,
but we never get a picture painted of what they really look like. Do they look
different than those in our world? I feel like I don’t have enough information
to visualize these places. Rips on Twilight.
I feel like every YA paranormal romance has to include a scene where a
clueless human mentions something in Twilight
and the savvy supernatural laughs at them—but you can’t make fun of a book
where a girl falls in love with a vampire in a book where a girl falls in love
with a demon. Use of third person omni POV. This is just a pet peeve. Name
similarity. We’ve got an Ashdad, an Alex, an Azira, an Adira, and an Aelek. Ack!
Did I like this story? Yes. Would I
read it again? Sure. Would I recommend it to people who like YA paranormal
romance? Yes. My rating? As a YA paranormal romance, four and a half stars out
of five. As a novel, three and a half stars.
--Liz Ellor, O43
You can download The First Book of Demons here